The Legal Deserts Problem-Solving Project:

a partnership between i4J and the National Center for State Courts (NCSC) with support from the State Justice Institute (SJI)

This project aggregates promising practices for greening legal deserts nationwide through Structure and System Impact Area work and brings together a cohort of courts in Michigan, Nevada, and Washington to explore strategies for localizing legal desert solutions in Service Impact Area work.

Legal deserts represent a significant and growing challenge: in over 50 percent of rural counties nationwide, a combination of lawyer shortages, high poverty rates, language access barriers, distance to courthouses, technology barriers, and legal service shortages leave community members navigating complex legal issues without legal supports. With generous support from the State Justice Institute (SJI), the National Center for State Courts (NCSC) has engaged in extensive legal deserts mapping, using GIS technology, to help courts and their justice system partners gain deeper insights into the needs of people living in legal deserts. More actionable research is needed, however, to help courts and their justice system partners understand the universe of the possible for legal desert interventions across a variety of the conditions that create legal deserts. Researchers have long called for data that helps “to identify region-specific legal and nonlegal problems and priorities … [and] how rural people access and interact with the legal system or about particular legal needs that are subsequently unrecognized or otherwise are going unaddressed.” 

The Legal Deserts Problem-Solving Project establishes an expansive inventory of existing and possible legal desert interventions. The Project also assembles a cohort of 3 state courts to engage in: (1) training regarding legal deserts and their possible solutions; (2) participatory action research in their jurisdictions to understand the unique conditions of the legal deserts in their state; (3) technical assistance in selecting and implementing right-sized legal desert solutions for their state.

Right-Sized Solution Building

This project convened a cohort of three courts: the 32nd Circuit Court in Ontonagon, Michigan, the Nevada Supreme Court Administrative Office of the Courts, and the Pacific and Wahkiakum Superior Court in Washington. The research team used the design and systems thinking process to understand the unique experience of each of these legal deserts and to identify right-sized solutions for their conditions, needs, and capacity.

Four ideas supported by data and insights in each jurisdiction were shared with open questions about what design choices are best suited for their communities:

Legal Helpers in Community: This idea trains, supports, and empowers community members to assist others with legal problems. The role of the helpful community member can vary from peer support, to court- or community-based navigation help, to community members trained and authorized to provide legal advice through unauthorized practice of law reform. The research team identified the following design choices for feedback during prototype testing: who the legal helper could be and where they are located; education, training, and scope; organizational affiliation; and focus areas.

Limited-Term Rural Attorney Fellowship: This idea centers on bringing attorneys-in-training and licensed attorneys to the jurisdiction for a specific amount of time, in recognition of national data that attempts to permanently place or relocate attorneys in legal desert jurisdictions are not working. Attorney fellowships are existing and contemplated in some jurisdictions, but so far have been largely untested with the communities that they seek to serve. This fellowship design is open-ended — this could be designed for law student participants, those summering or visiting the area as a tourist for vacation, attorneys interested in an “AmeriCorp” like experience, or attorneys thinking about retiring and moving somewhere new. The research team identified the following design choices for feedback during prototype testing: motivators for participation; attorney career stage for participation; duration; focus areas; and markers of credibility and trust.

Digital Form Navigator: This idea can take shape across a wide range of digital form assistance. The purpose of this idea is to provide tech-based help to community members who are completing forms and other court documents without any human help. This may include (re)designing e-file forms as fillable PDFs, layering forms with guided interviews that help people decide what form to use, a chatbot that provides information about what to put in each section, videos that explain the purpose and requirements for the forms, or a more cutting-edge AI navigator or assistant. The research team identified the following design choices for feedback during prototype testing: human roles in technology tools; what builds trust; topic areas; locations for interaction; and technology sophistication.

Self-Help Navigation Station: This idea connects court users to self-help materials and offers different ways of accessing them. Court users could go to a physical location where they know a self-help navigation station is waiting for them, or they could schedule a time to have the navigation station meet them at a place of their choosing. This self-help mobile navigation station may be digital or paper-based, or a combination of both. The research team identified the following design choices for feedback during prototype testing: the spectrum of paper to digital materials; the type of help people want from the station; the role of human support; and location and feasibility.

Ontonagon, Michigan

Ontonagon, Michigan, is located on the Upper Peninsula of the state on Lake Superior. Ontonagon County has a population of approximately 5,800 people. The County is 3,741 square miles and is the third-largest county in Michigan by area. Ontonagon averages about 187 inches of snowfall per year and 36 inches of rain.

44 system actors and 1 community member participated in interviews during the Empathy phase of this design research. These individuals were court staff, social service providers, government service providers, community-based organizations, lawyers, and legal educators. 19 court staff, legal educators, legal service providers, social service providers, and community members provided feedback on the ideas generated after interviews. Based on information shared in these interviews and feedback collected during the Prototype Testing phase of the design research, the research team recommends implementing the legal helpers in community idea. This idea trains, supports, and empowers community members to assist others with legal problems through navigation help. The research team recommends implementing this idea for the following reasons:

  • Michigan Legal Help has the training infrastructure and experience through the Community Legal Connector program that has been implemented elsewhere in the state; they are available and have the capacity to train Ontonagon community members in this program;

  • Community members want more court touch-points — community members often seek out court staff to ask questions. Having a dedicated roll within the court house to help with navigation assistance would be helpful and useful;

  • Court staff, legal service providers, legal educators, social service providers, and community members were all interested in this idea — feedback indicated that explaining documents, how to navigate the court process, and how to prepare for court proceedings would be helpful;

The self-help navigation station tested well among community members who wanted a station in a permanent spot in the community; this already exists at the courthouse as the Michigan Legal Help kiosk, so more community education and outreach about that resource is recommended. The limited-term attorney fellowship idea received positive feedback, though not as well as the legal helpers in community. There is more existing infrastructure and support to implement the legal helpers in community idea at this time. Tech-based help like the digital form navigator received negative feedback because of challenges with access and connectivity in the community. Community members want help from a human who can explain processes to them.


Elko County, Nevada

Elko County, Nevada, is located in northeastern Nevada, bordered by Idaho to the north and Utah to the east. Elko County spans 17,203 square miles, making it the fourth largest county by area in the contiguous United States. Elko County has an estimated population of approximately 54,800 people with many working in the mining industry.

21 system actors and 2 community members participated in interviews during the Empathy phase of this design research. These individuals were court staff, social service providers, lawyers, and legal educators. 44 court staff, legal educators, legal service providers, social service providers, and community members provided feedback on the ideas generated after interviews. Based on information shared in these interviews and feedback collected during the Prototype Testing phase of the design research, the research team recommends implementing the limited-term attorney fellowship idea. This idea centers on bringing attorneys-in-training and licensed attorneys to the jurisdiction for a specific amount of time, in recognition of national data that attempts to permanently place or relocate attorneys in legal desert jurisdictions are not working. The research team recommends implementing this idea for the following reasons:

  • Public defender and district attorney offices have increased pay to try to attract more attorneys to permanently relocate to the area, but it has not yet seen an increase;

  • Feedback from system actors and community members indicated that a fellowship of at least 6 months would be beneficial;

  • Case types that would be well-suited for this type of work include housing, family law, debt, and criminal first appearances;

  • Community members are open to continued professional relationships with attorneys once their fellowship concludes and they are no longer physically present in the community;

  • There is appetite and interest from legal educators in Nevada to involve law students and recent graduate in a rural attorney fellowship experience.

The legal helpers in community idea tested well among system actors as well, though community members showed a slight preference for the limited-term attorney fellowship. The digital form navigator idea also tested well among community members; the Nevada Administrative Office of the Courts is already working on initiatives that would incorporate design choices associated with the digital form navigator idea. Because of the vast geographic area, the self-help navigation station tested poorly with system actors and community members because there are insurmountable barriers to getting the navigation station to various points in the county.

Pacific and Wahkiakum County Superior Court, Washington

Pacific and Wahkiakum County Superior Court is located on the southwestern corner of Washington state. Pacific County has an estimated population of approximately 24,350 residents and encompasses about 1,223 square miles which includes 291 square miles of water. Key sectors in this area are tourism, commercial fishing, shellfish harvesting, and logging.

26 system actors and 5 community members participated in interviews during the Empathy phase of this design research. These individuals were court staff, social service providers, government service providers, community-based organizations, lawyers, and legal educators. 15 court staff, legal educators, legal service providers, and social service providers provided feedback on ideas. Despite outreach from court staff, social service providers, and the research team, community members did not provide feedback on ideas. Based on information shared in community interviews and feedback collected during the Prototype Testing phase of the design research, the research team recommends implementing the limited-term attorney fellowship idea. This idea centers on bringing licensed attorneys to the jurisdiction for a specific amount of time, in recognition of national data that attempts to permanently place or relocate attorneys in legal desert jurisdictions are not working. The research team recommends implementing this idea for the following reasons:

  • Community members want legal help from people who are trustworthy, listen, and will advocate for them;

  • Community members value help that is nearby;

  • Seattle University Law School offers programs intended to connect law students with rural areas, though these programs currently focus on other rural areas in Washington other than Pacific and Wahkiakum counties;

  • System actors think that attorneys who are later in their careers and thinking of retiring or who are looking for something new would have the most interest in participating;

  • System actors shared that financial incentives would be motivating for fellowship participation;

  • The Washington State Bar Association has a STAR (Small Town and Rural) council, indicating that attorneys statewide are aware of and passionate about meeting the legal needs in rural Washington.

The legal helpers in community idea received some positive feedback, though with some indication that those best-suited for the role would not be geographically located in Pacific County and instead be in neighboring Cowlitz County or in Oregon state. The digital form navigator idea tested poorly with system actors with hesitancy about tech literacy among community members causing skepticism about success. The inability of gathering community member feedback through online surveys supports this skepticism. The self-help navigation station also received low support.

Promising Practices for Greening Legal Deserts

The research team has been aggregating and synthesizing legal desert-focused promising practices that have been implemented or proposed across the country. This research scan includes scholarly articles, informational webpages, news articles, court rules, and administrative orders.

More information about promising practices coming soon!